As long as you and your staff are showing the basic appreciation throughout the year to all, like thank yous, how grateful you are that they are there, doing temperature checks to make sure they are enjoying what they do, then expressing gratitude through awards for those that go above and beyond throughout the year shouldn't be an issue. The point of awards and doing something extra for those volunteers is to show the organization recognizes that they are giving more than normal, whether it's time, a home for fosters, etc. If certain volunteers express irritation with these awards, then ultimately their time volunteering isn't about volunteering and giving back, it's about themselves. We've never had anyone say that they were upset about the individual praise for others, however that doesn't mean someone didn't feel "left out". We do change the awards every year, recognize the most outstanding "new volunteer", etc so it's not the same people every year. But I find it's more important to praise those volunteers that make a significant difference at our shelter rather than worry about the repercussions or backlash of doing something extra for certain volunteers. However, I can't stress enough it comes down making sure there is day to day acknowledgement of everyone that volunteers. This will help with anyone that doesn't get an award at the end of the year.
#PeopleManagement