Animal Welfare Professionals

 View Only
  • 1.  How big does your shelter need to be?

    Posted 01-04-2023 07:36 AM
    So I was having a conversation with some peer shelter directors last night and we discussed that to our knowledge, there is not a formula out there to determine if your shelter is big enough for your community. Does anyone have a calculator that looks at things like community human population, pet population, average annual intake, calls for service etc. that determines how big a shelter should be for that community?

    Hoping maybe some of the shelter architects are on here and can weigh in. I think as community populations change so much (I know of a large city whose shelter was built when the human population was 400,000 and it is now in excess of 2 million!), it can help us make a case for either additional shelter capacity, or better yet, why managed intake is a necessity if the imbalance is significant.
    #OrganizationalManagement

    ------------------------------
    Alexis Pugh
    Director, Memphis Animal Services
    www.memphisanimalservices.com

    Organizational Management
    & Pet Support Services Specialist
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: How big does your shelter need to be?

    Posted 01-05-2023 11:58 AM
    I think it depends on your programs, how you do intakes, your demographics, and your community's leadership.
    And this, of course can change over time.

    As a rule of thumb:
    AVMA estimates the average number of dogs per household is 1.6 and the number of cats is 1.8
    HSUS estimates shelter intake as 3% of the human population. 
    So you can start from there and estimate how many animals will come in over the course of a year, and adjusting for those peaks you have for kitten season, how many fosters you have at one time, etc. to determine total maximum capacity required.  You'd have to contact your local planning department to find out what the projected growth is for the jurisdiction you serve to plan ahead for future space needs.  

    HSUS has more stats if you want to dive deeper into the numbers:
    https://humanepro.org/page/pets-by-the-numbers

    Our city did a study in 2016 to determine how much expansion we would need to accommodate the population growth by 2040.  Our average (animal) intake was 2% of the (human) population.  Based on a projected 40% population growth, and the current 5% space deficit, we determined we would need 47% more space to house the resulting increase in animals by 2040.

    In 2012 we took in 1,614 dogs and 1,881 cats.  In 2016 we took in 1,273 dogs and 471 cats.  Last year (2022) we took in 593 dogs and 525 cats.  This decrease, despite the fact that due to the Camp Fire in 2018, our population has already exceeded growth estimate projections for 2040!  So we should be taking in way more animals than we did in 2012, not less.  But we changed some of our policies regarding healthy stray cats (don't take them) and partnered with our local TNR group for healthy neighborhood cats.  We are doing more (dog) return to owner in the field, plus offer free microchipping and free tags for all dogs and cat in our community.  We take in all stray dogs same day, but put non-urgent surrenders on a wait list and help owners with rehoming resources, so by the time we call them back about 40-50% have already rehomed their pets.  We use 100% foster homes for all our under aged kittens until they are old enough to come back for spay/neuter and adoption.  If we had not put those policies in place, we would have easily exceeded our capacity for care at the shelter years ago.  That doesn't mean we don't need a new facility, we do, since part of it was built in 1956 and part in 1987, but from a space prespective, we're doing ok.

    Hope that helps a little :-)

    ------------------------------
    Tracy Mohr
    Animal Services Manager
    City of Chico Animal Services
    5308945630
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: How big does your shelter need to be?

    Posted 01-05-2023 12:30 PM
    Thanks Tracy!

    ------------------------------
    Alexis Pugh
    Director, Memphis Animal Services
    www.memphisanimalservices.com

    Organizational Management
    & Pet Support Services Specialist
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: How big does your shelter need to be?

    Posted 01-05-2023 12:40 PM

    Alexis,

    I thought I'd share some information as we often work with shelters in right sizing a facility. There isn't - to my knowledge - an all encompassing formula for shelter size for a community but there are some good tools available.  One can do some ballpark capacity calculations for housing numbers for dogs and cats(or any other species) using intake numbers and average length of stay. Here are some calculators that my be of use:   https://www.sheltermedicine.com/library/shelter-capacity-calculators/ 

    One can also look at intakes on a per capita basis – per 1000 population served. A number of years ago we did some work looking at per capita intakes across California and it varied from about 5 to over 20 per 1000 people served- (for dogs and cats each). So a community with a human population of 300,000 might have between 1500 and 6000  intakes of cats or dogs annually.  In many communities at that time dog and cat intake numbers were similar- so if dog  intake was ~1500 – we generally saw intakes for cats about 1500 as well (and commonly it was more).  In many shelters now we see fewer cat intakes than dogs.

    It's interesting and kind of counter intuitive but increases in human population in a community has not been correlated with increases in shelter animal intakes- at least historically.  In many communities the trends in shelter intakes stabilize or decrease with human population growth. This has been especially true for feline intakes over the last 5-8 years where best practices have been implemented. 

    Another tool to put to use is length of stay(LOS). Its impact on capacity is huge.  In an existing facility if there is room to shorten the average LOS – this will help to decrease daily care needs – overall less animal inventory and open up capacity.  For new buildings  - going from a more traditional facility design model of holding areas and adoption areas to an open selection model (where there is generally a mix of hold and adoption housing together) or some hybrid there of will decrease the average LOS such that the capacity needs for the shelter may be able to be decreased. 

    Shelter size and related "capacity" are highly dependent on resources. We often talk about capacity for care – in a nutshell and from a facility standpoint - it's the operational relationship between available humane housing units and available care staff such that animal, people and organization needs are met.  Mismatches here are especially difficult. Reduction in resources (funding and/or staffing) can limit a shelter's "capacity".  A good reason for operating via managed intake is that it's a more nimble operational model and as changes occur in staffing or funding the capacity can be adjusted to better meet the available resources. 

    Programs offered also impact capacity and capacity needs.  Those programs that help to serve people and animals outside the shelter(preventing intakes) or that shorten LOS when in shelter – things like: spay/neuter, return to home in the field, wellness care, managed intake, daily rounds,  food banks, phone bank to answer questions, foster programs, etc, etc.  So understanding what programs are going to be in use or put into use can help in right sizing a facility too.  What I like about these programs is there is often time to put some of these into play in existing facilities – prior to designing a new facility such that capacity needs will be more clear when it comes time to build.

    Hope this is of some help.  Always happy to discuss if there is more interest. 

    Thanks,

     

    Denae Wagner DVM, MPVM

    UC Davis, Koret Shelter Medicine Program

    www.sheltermedicine.com

    Link to everything PORTALS!

    Faculty, Maddie's Million Pet Challenge