It sounds like somebody offered a suggestion to some issue that arose or was anticipated, and they accepted it without considering unintended consequences. Based on my experience having served on a couple of different boards, studied board development over the years, and worked in human resources doing recruiting, that looks shortsighted.
I recommend the entire board get some education on the subject. I'm sure there are free webinars on board development somewhere. Even YouTube has some great stuff! I suggest looking for Board Recruitment.
Of course the ED and staff would be the best people to offer suggestions for board nominations! That does not at all mean they have a hand in the process, or influence it in any way.
The process starts with appointing a nominating committee, not with limiting the recruitnent pool (amacks head very hard)! GOOD LUCK.
------------------------------
Norma Wallace
Consultant
Writing for Results
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 04-21-2023 09:19 AM
From: Anonymous Member
Subject: Community Conversations - 4/24/23 - How to Diversify Your Board
This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous
I'm looking forward to this call!
I was wondering how in-depth you will go into board recruitment tactics? I've been experiencing some struggles with my board regarding this topic. Very recently they have shifted their approach to recruitment to 100% exclude any staff input (including from the Executive Director). I completely acknowledge that an ED/CEO should avoid conflicts of interest and would not have an actual vote when determining if a new member will be welcomed to the board, but as I also understand it, best practice is to use the ED/CEO resources, contacts, and knowledge of the community and organization to identify potential board members that would align with the mission vision and values of the organization. Also, knowing if a potential board member and ED/CEO will work well together doesn't seem like a bad idea to me either - after all those relationships are CRITICAL to the success of a nonprofit.
Would love some additional insight into this topic! Thanks. :)