I share your feelings. Happily, the shelter I volunteer with does not enforce a designated quiet time. Our building is shut down, locked up, lights out from 17:00 to 07:00 every day. All staff and volunteers leave for the day. And, sometimes on holidays and weekends it locks down much earlier. A lot of the dogs are not getting out of kennel more than 10 minutes a day at a minimum of 2 times a day, and that's just for a potty break and doesn't include any enrichment. We don't have enough visitors and potential adopters passing through to really create distress for the dogs. l I know this topic has support on both sides, and I've seen one research article that supports it, although; it wasn't strong enough to convince me. I can't understand how more isolation is helpful for the dogs?? I've also visited a rehabilitation center for fearful dogs that does a shut down for one hour. They call it Zen time. I could live with that, if required to. I hope to read more on this topic here.
------------------------------
Robert Lucas
Retired/Volunteer
APS of Durham
NC
------------------------------