Animal Welfare Professionals

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

community support for TNR

  • 1.  community support for TNR

    Posted 10-03-2023 01:13 PM

    My post is a question regarding how to tap into public care and concern for animal welfare by educating them about the priority of spay/neuter.  More specifically the importance of TNR in reducing the number of cats and kittens in shelters.   I believe there is not nearly  enough emphasis by humane societies and other large animal welfare organizations on the urgent need for TNR groups and funding .  TNR is on the peripheral of what is focused on and deemed important.  How do we bring TNR to the center of our focus?  It comes down to more emphasis on prevention.


    #CommunityPartnerships*
    #DataandTechnology
    #FundraisingandDevelopment

    ------------------------------
    Holly Hocker
    board member
    Friends of Woodford County IL, Feral cats
    IL
    ------------------------------



  • 2.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-04-2023 01:06 AM

    Hi Holly, it's Holly :)

    This is a great question and something we are dealing with here too in Hawaii.  We have a robust TNR movement here but there are so many people who don't understand why we do it and how it helps.  Recently we had a Senator write a bill to ask for funding for TNR.  His plan was that every resident in the state had an OPTION to check a box on their tax return stating that they wanted a small portion of their tax refund (like $5 each) to go toward funding TNR. We were so excited.  The biggest person to oppose it was a guy from the American Bird Conservancy.  He was totally against - NOT the funding, but TNR in general because he doesn't want the cats "returned" to where they came from because a fixed cat could still kill birds.  He totally missed the point that a fixed cat won't make MORE cats that will eat even MORE birds!  The state financial department complained that it would be too much work for them.  SO frustrating.  Aloha from O'ahu, Hawaii!



    ------------------------------
    Holly Holowach
    Founder/President
    Popoki Place O'ahu Cat Sanctuary
    HI
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-05-2023 03:24 PM

    Hello! This is a great question, and unfortunately I don't have any ideas either. I live in a small, rural area and people are always complaining about all the cats. We have one very small TNR group, but they're not super active because there are only a few of them, not enough vets, and not enough funding.  Convincing people that just getting rid of the cats isn't the answer is nearly impossible. I can tell them all the benefits of TNR and they don't want to hear it, so I'm interested in hearing ideas as well.



    ------------------------------
    Sincerely,
    Johanna Spielman
    Founder of Jamie Brianna's Legacy Fund
    https://jamiebriannaslegacyfund.org/
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-06-2023 04:05 AM

    Hi Holly,

              My best suggestion is to continue to share TNR information on social media all of the time.  I have been truly amazed when scanning local community posts how many people know about TNR and are supportive of it.  If people are against TNR, they are usually not against s/n for owned pets so you might start out from that angle.  I find that if a community has enough s/n and TNR s/n capacity then the community is more receptive to using those services.  Educating folks about TNR with out easy/affordable access to appointments doesn't help much unfortunately.    

               If you are concerned about reducing the number of kittens in the shelter another very viable approach is to get all of our local veterinarians to offer feline fix by five.  https://www.unitedspayalliance.org/feline-fix-by-five/.   Dr. Phil Bushby has spoken at length that if we just got the standard practice of s/n to be before 5 months or the first heat, this would reduce the number of kittens in our shelters significantly.    Do you think the local private practice veterinarians would be willing to consider this change?  Right now with the vet shortage, this may be the best approach to having impacts in our shelters.

               In terms of strategy- just doing TNR won't help reduce the number of cats in your shelter without access to affordable s/n of owned cats.  So just be aware of the fact that s/n capacity right now is very important to make changes and our focus should be building up capacity in every community through different models(mash, voucher, private practice, mobile, stationary) there are lots of options. But that is off topic, sorry. 

              Anyway, here are some options.  I am happy to expand more.  Thank you so very much for everything that you do help cats!

               



    ------------------------------
    Stacy LeBaron
    Head Cat
    The Community Cats Podcast
    Warren VT
    978-239-2090
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-14-2023 10:52 AM

    I asked Stacy off-discussion what is a mash model and thought I should share her answer in case others may have the same question. 

    Hi Gwen;

      Mash style clinics are where you go into a space(auditorium, private clinic-other) and use that space to do surgeries for a day and then move out.  They are usually run by volunteers and held monthly.  There are some vets who have programs where they are mash style/mobile where they go from one location to another but that is a bit different.   The MRFRS(www.mrfrs.org) has Sunday clinics every month. 



    ------------------------------
    Gwen Harding-Peets
    Board Member, trapper, S/N certificate coordinator, adoption coordinator
    PANT
    Dutchess County, NY
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-06-2023 04:08 PM

    Our city and county shelter do not accept healthy cats nor do they provide TNR.  The city shelter director told me he believes cats should be left on the street but he would TNR if funds were donated for that purpose. He was just awarded best shelter director from some group. The county shelter stopped accepting healthy cats in 2014 but will accept sick/injured cats, I assume they euthanize them, and those unable to self-feed. They  reach out to local rescue groups to take any cats or kittens.  Our elected officials are not interested, either. I regularly ask citizens to contact their elected official about TNR but no one does. Our climate allows for year round breeding. 

    I know it's a sad situation here but I have hope and many ideas to improve our situation. A media campaign could make it "cool" to like cats and cool to spay neuter them. Funding to provide spay neuter for those unable to afford it is another plan. I can speak to community groups to educate on TNR.  Turning cat haters into cat helpers is part of the effort, too. People don't like snakes or rats, so cats can be part of the solution to that issue. We have to change the way people feel about cats in general. 



    ------------------------------
    Valerie Blankenship
    Mobile Bay Cats
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-13-2023 04:49 PM

    Hi Valerie -

    At first I thought you were talking about one of our shelters, who just won a big award, but they hardly take anything other than lost and found.  I've even heard they only take animals that are microchipped so they are easily reunited and tell folks to put the animals back.  Our other huge shelter wants ZERO to do with TNR, community cat, and feral cat programs.
    Some things we are doing to get the word out about TNR or helping fix lower income pets is we have some volunteers who work at clinics and they have convinced the clinic management to have a clinic for us, for free, for 15-20 cats a month. We focus on friendlies that are owned, that don't qualify for the TNR slots at our HQHVSN clinic. Another thing we do is highlight our trappers on social media and have photos of them in groups, so it doesn't seem so lonely (because it can be). Those posts show camaraderie, friendship and fun, all for TNR.  It's easier to do outreach as a team as well - you don't look like a "crazy old cat lady". 
    But capacity will continue to be an issue unfortunately, but we are seeing big differences in areas where we have done high intensity TNR. 



    ------------------------------
    Karen Jealous
    PDX Cat Trapper
    Portland OR
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-19-2023 06:00 PM

    Thank you for the feedback.



    ------------------------------
    Valerie Blankenship
    Mobile Bay Cats
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-16-2023 09:27 AM

    Hi Valerie,

    I'm really confused (concerned!).  Your county shelter only takes in sick/injured cats and euthanizes them? They don't accept healthy animals? And the shelter manager thinks cats should live on the streets? It sounds like you and others like you need to begin to act politically.  Alley Cat Allies has lots of information/guide for TNR activism.  I hope things get better for you and the cats.  A lot of misinformation is out there, and education can help!

    Cat Advocacy | How to Pass Laws to Help Community Cats and Kittens (alleycat.org)

    www.alleycat.org



    ------------------------------
    Erin Hooks
    NC
    ------------------------------



  • 10.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-16-2023 03:58 PM

    HI Erin - 
    We are seeing very similar actions by our local animal services.  Our main county is extremely limited on what they take AND we just had a situation where a very friendly young adult cat was taken into the ER with a broken leg, that had been broken for a while. The cat was doing well otherwise, previously had been spayed and was in good condition. Unfortunately our county animal shelter euthanized her instead of transferring her to a rescue partner. We are seeing them continue to turn cats away, even if they are sick kittens found in their county. They are telling folks to "put them back outside so they can find their way home" even for abandoned animals, animals known to belong to people who have moved and left them.  They are NOT taking in healthy animals for admission. 
    They are also adopting out unfixed animals, with their voucher usage between 6-20%. We are finding many cats with kittens that are microchipped, unfixed, adopted out from the county shelter. It's very frustrating.
    Even more frustrating is the adjacent county doesn't even handle cats. They tell people who call for injured cats that their Sheriff can come and shoot it for them. So as a TNR/rescue group, we are dealing with some folks who are hysterical and desperate by the time they reach us. 
    Oh, throw in the fact that our local newspaper just highlighted that an audit found our County animal services has over $2 MILLION dollars of unspent donor funds, specifically donated to vet care over the past 5 years. TWO MILLION DOLLARS. That could pay for a lot of spay and neuter services and a few vets.



    ------------------------------
    Karen Jealous
    PDX Cat Trapper
    Portland OR
    ------------------------------



  • 11.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-19-2023 06:28 PM

    Erin, thank you for replying. It is extremely concerning and confusing. I think Alley Cat Allies recommendations were ill used. I'm told Alley Cat Allies visited our county shelter around 2014, after a lawsuit resulted when a kitten was euthanized within 7 minutes of arrival, while the owner was searching for it.  You can probably confirm if Alley Cat Allies visited Mobile, AL, around that time. The lawsuit led to some changes. The county shelter director, now retired, told me the visiting professional organization said the cats should be left on the street but TNR should be implemented.  The shelter was indeed euthanizing large numbers at the time. The shelter stopped taking healthy cats/kittens but TNR was given a little money for a one time effort to TNR. A local nonprofit was given $5K to TNR. After that, no more TNR.  

    The City Shelter Director told me he believes cats should be left on the street but he will support TNR if funds become available. The city referred someone to me for TNR recently. 

    The County Shelter does not accept healthy cats. When they do accept sick, injured cats or nursing kittens, with no queen, they reach out to local rescue groups to take them.  Nursing kittens without a queen are euthanized if no local group takes them. I cannot say how many are euthanized. I suspect local groups take all the nursing kittens. 

    I agree we need to act politically. All local groups working together is my ideal. I look to Alley Cat Allies and will delve into the links you shared.  Haven't found traction with our elected officials yet but will continue to work on it. Any advice is welcomed. 



    ------------------------------
    Valerie Blankenship
    Mobile Bay Cats
    ------------------------------



  • 12.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-16-2023 05:52 PM

    Hello there!

    We are lucky to have a great volunteer run our TNR program. Washington State has a program through the vanity license plates that has some funding for TNR in addition to other s/n of owned pets. We're trying to tap into that funding. We have great word of mouth in our community overall and that helps us get the word out to other community serving organizations who can help spread the word about the program. We are also limited in the veterinary care aspect and looking for ways to hold clinics along with supporting the colony caretakers with food or supplies as needed. 



    ------------------------------
    Traci Tingley
    Grant Writer
    West Columbia Gorge Humane Society
    WA
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-20-2023 07:27 AM

    The problem in our area is that TNR is technically illegal. There are no programs for it because city law prohibits it. In order to trap, you have to feed and you aren't allowed to feed the strays. Granted there are some of us doing it anyway. Recently someone reported a lady for it. Animal control hid in the area where she was feeding the colony, followed her home, and wrote her a $1000 ticket for feeding them. Since she has been feeding them for more than 3 days, they said they are now all her personal cats. You are allowed 5 animals total. So every cat (in her home and in her colony) that exceed the 5, is another fine of like $20 or $50/day. They gave her a week. 
    Also mind you, or our local animal control will not take owner surrenders either. Sooooo - You can see how they skirt around this issue with their archaic laws. Meanwhile, the cats just roam & reproduce and they do nothing about it unless people complain. In which  they trap and euthanize since they are feral.
    No one involved in TNR wants to go to the city and press the issue because they don't want their name on the radar. And anyone not involved doesn't care enough to go fight for it.



    ------------------------------
    Sarah Hoadley
    Paws in Middle Georgia Animal Rescue
    ------------------------------



  • 14.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-21-2023 01:09 PM

    This is so evil and, after reading , ruined my day.  Humans are the worst.  I hope and pray that someone from Maddie's Fund can respond to this with advice / help.



    ------------------------------
    Maurna
    ------------------------------



  • 15.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-21-2023 10:02 PM

    Hi Sarah,

    We are in a similar situation - the city does not take cats.  It is illegal to feed them, therefore, TNR doesn't work.  We are hoping to put together a program and approach the city. 



    ------------------------------
    Connie Ash
    Director
    Mended Paws Sanctuary
    AR
    ------------------------------



  • 16.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-22-2023 01:19 PM

    I'm finding it difficult to comprehend how the city can effectively manage the issue of cat overpopulation if they neither permit people to feed feral cats nor support programs like TNR. How do they propose to address this challenge without such crucial measures in place?

    At the moment, I am actively engaged in learning how to craft a successful TNR program. My hope is to garner support from individuals, volunteers, businesses, and government entities to help bring this initiative to fruition.

    I would love to hear from you and your experience with this program.



    ------------------------------
    Myriam Martinez
    President
    Mujeres Latinas SC
    SC
    ------------------------------



  • 17.  RE: community support for TNR

    Posted 10-22-2023 02:12 PM

    Oh, my god, Sarah, this is horrific!!!!  I cannot believe you all have to endure such backward thinking!  You need to stand together as a huge group and get some powerful backing like from Best Friends Animal Society or your local humane society or someone in office and stand up to the people who enforce this law.  Go to the Mayor or the City Council and work as a team.  I am SO sad for you and the animals.  This is exactly the wrong thing to do for the animals and terrifying for the feeders! 



    ------------------------------
    Holly Holowach
    Founder/President
    Popoki Place O'ahu Cat Sanctuary
    HI
    ------------------------------