Animal Welfare Professionals

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

  • 1.  Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-11-2024 12:16 PM

    Hi everyone! Our shelter has always had a court-ordered community service (COCS) program, but we seem to be having more issues with the volunteers in the program as of late. Can you please let us know if you welcome this type of volunteerism at your shelter, and the guidelines/protocols for the program? Links or documents would be greatly appreciated as we audit our program!


    #PeopleManagement(includingVolunteerIntegration)

    ------------------------------
    jennifer hatcher
    Director of Development
    Humane Society for Hamilton County
    Fishers IN
    ------------------------------



  • 2.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-12-2024 07:11 AM

    I had been mulling over whether or not to more actively recruit volunteers that have some type of requirement (court ordered, school, etc). I have no experience with these types of volunteers, but it seems like a good source of volunteer personnel. I hadn't given much thought to potential problems. If you don't mind me asking, what types of issues are you having? 



    ------------------------------
    Brandon Scivolette
    Technology Oversight Volunteer
    Rebels Rescue, Inc
    https://www.rebelsrescue.com
    Tampa FL
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-12-2024 07:24 AM

    The largest challenge we've faced since moving into our new facility and greatly increasing our volunteer base has been oversight of the community service volunteers. For example, just recently we learned that a volunteer went into an unauthorized area of the facility and took out a small dog on a walk that they were interested in – even though our community service program clearly outlines that volunteers do not handle animals, and they were told the area was for staff only. It seems as though many would need direct supervision, which of course is difficult as an animal shelter always at our max bandwidth.

    Because of recent incidents, we are contemplating closing the community service program to the public and only allowing volunteers on a case-by-case basis.



    ------------------------------
    Jennifer Hatcher
    Director of Development
    Humane Society for Hamilton County
    Fishers, IN
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-12-2024 09:09 AM

    Yes, we do but it's all case by case.  We limit it to minor offenses and depending on the hours they need or if they wish to continue volunteering or not afterward, we try to fit their actual volunteer duty into that framework.  We don't have a shelter, we're foster based & largely virtual, so it's a little more challenging.  Fostering isn't one of options because it's hard to quantify and we don't want to be in a position of having to place a pet a second time.   We do allow for transports & taking care of the cat habitat for in person options.  And we have a number of virtual teams a person can join if they are interested in continuing to volunteer.  Hours are managed by the lead of the team the person is volunteering on and then a letter is written once complete.



    ------------------------------
    Kim Kay
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-12-2024 09:10 AM

    Yes we do, specifically for morning cleaning help and we usually do not take anyone that needs more than 40 hours or has a long history/felonies, unless it's a first time offense. I also don't take CS for people under 18 - the maturity level just hasn't been there in my experience and I couldn't rely on them to make their shifts. 

    We inform them of the rules before they agree to start by email and go over it again in their paperwork on their first day. We sometimes have issues and have to talk to them about it. Our rule is we will talk to them once about an issue, and after that we will dismiss them and depending on the severity of the issue, may not agree to sign off on any of their hours, which we also inform them of. We rarely have to dismiss them after having a conversation with them. Since it's morning cleaning we also have other staff around to monitor. 



    ------------------------------
    Dani Wagner
    Volunteer Programs Manager
    Humane Fort Wayne
    IN
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-18-2024 06:46 AM

    Hello everyone,

    The biggest issue we have with this is the amount of time it takes to train someone who only needs a very few number of hours so we look at that, along with the results of a background check, before deciding on moving forward.  



    ------------------------------
    Franny Kent
    Director of Volunteers
    Bideawee
    NY
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-18-2024 09:05 AM

    Hello, I'm with Angels With Paws Cat Rescue in Lakewood, CO and we offer Community Service Volunteer Program at our rescue.  Wenonly offer ot for certain offenses and they can only participate in the AM cleaning at the facility. It has worked well for us and having extra hands on days when staff is light is always great. Our CS volunteer are always hard workslers and seem to really like helping the cats. 



    ------------------------------
    Elizabeth Talamantez
    Executive Director
    Angels With Paws
    Arvada, CO
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-19-2024 06:55 AM

    Years ago I worked at a small shelter that took people for court-ordered community service, and we loved them. We did not accept people with certain offenses (I think relating to children or violence, or maybe felonies in general). Usually the court-ordered volunteers were adults, were expecting to work, and had an ethic to complete their hours within a certain time frame. They chatted less and were without drama. We had one person who needed a significant number of hours and had to fit them in around her job, so it was like having a part-time employee for several months.

    I'd also counsel against generalizing issues with single persons to the whole category of court-ordered volunteers. Instead, consider what factors or failures of the system led to that specific situation and whether/how those ought to be addressed. Cancelling the program might be an overreaction.



    ------------------------------
    James Pawlowicz
    Humane Rescue Alliance
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-19-2024 09:11 AM

    I, along with my commissioners have halted all volunteer programs, and other community service programs due to several negative outcomes. It seemed that the input of time training them, versus how long they were in the programs, and if they were really any help and more of a hinderance came down to it wasn't worth it.  Also, the liability was of major concern with our small staff trying to oversee them and complete our work. After one particularly, bad day, we spent 2 extra hours of our time "fixing" and paperwork. The additional stress added to the job, just wasn't worth it. 

    I asked another warden how she managed to find such good help, and I quickly learned through her giggles, that 1 out of 50 was worth the time and effort. 

    Good Luck 



    ------------------------------
    Dee Cummins
    Dog Warden/Operations Manager
    Meigs County Rescue & Adoption Center
    OH
    ------------------------------



  • 10.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-20-2024 11:49 AM

    I have offered this at my shelters, but it is always case by case and we don't allow anyone with a violent crime to volunteer. Out of safety concerns, I usually do not have them working on anything that interacts with the animals. I will have them help with old paperwork scanning, cleaning empty kennels, laundry, computer admin help, etc. The need is pretty sporadic, so I try to keep a list of tasks that are not time sensitive and can wait for someone needing hours. 



    ------------------------------
    Nikki Healy
    Executive Director
    Good Mews Animal Foundation
    GA
    ------------------------------



  • 11.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-22-2024 07:03 AM

    We used to, but I ran into a lot of issues with it -  people exaggerating their hours, goofing off on time-sensitive work (i.e. we need to finish cleaning before we open in the mornings), no-show/no-call for shifts, etc. This was especially common with younger individuals (16-20ish years old) whose parents insert themselves into the process; I've had parents tell me to my face that being here is their kid's punishment! That is not a good way to start a volunteer relationship.  It just wasn't worth it when most of them don't really want to be here and never come in again after they complete their hours. 

    We now have this wording on our website and the top of the volunteer application: *Please note that the Roanoke Valley SPCA cannot assist with lawyer recommended or court-mandated community service hours.* 

    Side note: I have made exceptions for CURRENT volunteers who end up needing court-ordered hours for minor offenses (so they were volunteering before they were required to by court). 



    ------------------------------
    Erin Dams
    Community Relations Coordinator
    Roanoke Valley SPCA
    Roanoke VA
    ------------------------------



  • 12.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-23-2024 03:20 AM

    We get community service volunteers as well at our County run shelter.  We make them stay with the workers at all times.  They clean the cages with them or whatever is being done that day.  If they don't stay on task then they don't get their time counted.   We don't ask them to tell us in advance when they are coming because there ARE a lot of no shows!  They are just used as extra help.



    ------------------------------
    Candice Tousignant
    Treasurer
    Southern paws animal rescue
    KY
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-23-2024 07:21 AM

    Hey Jennifer! 

     I run Volunteers & Events at my shelter, and we do allow CSR volunteers on site. I inherited the volunteer program about 2 years ago and was very hesitant to make changes to it but I feel comfortable enough now that I plan on completely leveling the program and rebuilding it from the ground up early in 2025. With that said one of the tasks I've taken on recently is having more structure to our CSR program.  We added guidelines and put them in our volunteer SOP. Essentially it's case by case, when someone reaches out they must provide me with their court ordered paperwork and birthdate; I send that info to our PD and they tell me "minor traffic violations" or more recently "aggravated assault against a public servant"..... As a general rule we do not take any offenses involving sexual assault, violence, theft, drug use (other than marijuana), all the biggies. So we mainly do truancy, traffic violations,  stuff like that. I also have a welcome email I now send them when they are "onboarded" that lays out the expectations on our end and let them know if they do not follow these expectations, they will be cut as a CSR. I have no problem kicking someone out of the program who thinks this is an "easy out" for their hours. NAHHHHHH you're going to work and work hard when you're here to pay back your debt. I also don't allow cell phone usage as the younger kids will sit on their phones the entire shift vs fold laundry. Next step is making an actual contract/agreement for them to sign after they onboarded. I allow CSR hours to be completed 7 days a week; but ALL shifts begin at 830am. You aren't rolling in at noon after sleeping in and taking your time. You will be here when staff gets here or you aren't doing hours that day. I don't care if they choose to do 2 hours or 8hrs a shift, I let them decide that they have to be here at 830am. I also add everyone to our internal calendar so my kennel staff know who to expect, when and for how long. I allow them to decide where the CSRs will best fit help wise for their day with the hours they will be here, etc.

    I don't actively recruit CSRs but our local courthouse literally has us down as a place to report to, but I don't allow anyone to start hours until PD has cleared them and then we go from there. I've had to ask several not to return due to not wanting to actually do anything. Their court aide (?) not sure exactly who she is, reaches out and when I let her know why they were let go, it's never been an issue for us.

    I'm not going to lie it can be a HUGE headache some days... like earlier this week. A woman is past her due date to complete her hours. She has never reached out but called Monday while I was off then came up to the shelter Tuesday (also when I'm off) and caused a scene in the lobby that shes been trying to get a hold of me. Mind you... first contact was the day before. Then sent an email from the lobby to the front desk.. not even the volunteer email which is listed on her court paperwork along with my direct phone line... saying "3rd attempt at trying to get ahold of you". Like NO MA'M. you are NOT going to sit there and try to make ME look bad and like I'm not doing my job. Court aide contacted me Wednesday wanting to know what was going on with said woman and I let her know all of the listed above info and she was like yeahhhh no. She couldn't even tell me times/dates of trying to contact you, she's already past due, we aren't extending her hours to complete CSR she now has to pay her fine. 

     Sorry for the novel .. but in all fairness, most of our CSRs have been either great or at least good while here. Several have choosen to stay on as volunteers, become fosters or part of our transport team.

    This is their onboarding email:

    Hello,

    You've been cleared to do your CS hours here at Grand Prairie Animal Services under the Grand Prairie Police Department. We offer community service 7 days a week. ALL shifts begin at 830am. They can be as long as you'd like within our workday schedule. You can begin as soon as tomorrow.  You will be allowed into the building when you are scheduled on the calendar. You will be handling animals, cleaning kennels, as well as doing laundry and dishes when there is down time. If you are unable to do these things or stay on task while you are here, your CS internship will be ended.

    Dress code: please wear pants/jeans, closed toe shoes/nonslip shoes, and generally clothing you don't mind getting dirty.

    As a notice : If you are late to your shift, you will not be accepted that day to complete your shift.

    Also we do not allow phone usage while you are completing hours. If you have an emergency, please notify your shift lead.

    Please let me know what days you would like to come in and how long you would like each shift to be. I will ensure they are added to the calendar for a smooth transition.

    When you arrive for your first shift, you will call the Senior Animal Care Technicians work cell since the doors will be locked when you arrive. Let them know your outside and here for community service. They will let you in and get you started. I will provide you with the phone number once we have scheduled your first shift.

    If you have any questions, please let me know.

    Thank you,

    GPAS Programs Team



    ------------------------------
    Angellee Vincent
    Volunteer & Events Coordinator
    Grand Prairie Animal Services
    Grand Prairie, TX
    www.gptx.org/paws
    ------------------------------



  • 14.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-24-2024 08:58 AM

    Hi Angellee:
    I liked reading your letter that goes out to the CSR folks with your expectations laid out right at the beginning. I had to chuckle at your dress code: we had a volunteer show up one day wearing jeans (as appropriate) but a very short crop top that left a lot of skin showing! We ended up giving her a scrub top to wear for the rest of the day. So... you may want to add appropriate an appropriate shirt to your dress code too! (We sure did!) 



    ------------------------------
    Kirsten Cianci, VMD
    Palmetto Animal League
    Ridgeland, SC 29936
    =^..^=
    ------------------------------



  • 15.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-24-2024 12:28 PM

    We've been very fortunate.  We treat our CSR volunteers like we treat all the other volunteers.  Orientation, training, and nearly all our volunteers work with a staff member as lead on the shift.  We've had two CSR volunteers that we ended up hiring.  The ones who aren't suited to our program, scheduling, etc. quickly learn they're not a good fit for us and they move on.  We only had one who gave us some headaches over scheduling and hours, but no one has been really troublesome.  Probably because our CSR people are for things like minor drug possession, DUI, traffic.  NOTHING VIOLENT.  

    I have family in the Indianapolis area :)



    ------------------------------
    Crystal Swann Blackdeer
    Executive Director
    Leavenworth County Humane Society, Inc.
    Lansing KS
    913-250-0506
    ------------------------------



  • 16.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 11-25-2024 03:00 PM

    I do not run a shelter but my org does get a lot of court ordered volunteers. For years they have been some of the most dependable people we could ask for. When seeking volunteers you almost always fall victim to flake rate. Even some of the most reliable people can still either show up late or feel fine giving you reasoning of why they can't come. We have found them to be the most reliable of all. We tend to just need to extend an olive branch to them for them to understand the mission. When they aren't there by choice that doesn't mean they don't care. When they are informed as to why they should care they end up buying in more than anyone else. It is as simple as they would like to make the best of their situation. So we just need to help them understand why serving with our group was a blessing in disguise for both sides.



    ------------------------------
    Hakeem Ruiz
    Director
    CARE
    PA
    ------------------------------



  • 17.  RE: Court-Ordered Community Service Volunteerism

    Posted 12-04-2024 09:05 AM

    We do allow court ordered community service (COCS).  The person must be 18 years or older.  They are responsible for doing things such as laundry, dishes, sweeping, mopping, and refilling supplies around the shelter; they are not handling the animals.  The majority of our COCS people are reliable and helpful; we have actually had some continue to volunteer (go through our PAWS volunteer program) after their COSC has been completed.  We do not allow COCS if the charges are domestic violence, animal cruelty, illegal drugs (use or intent to sell), or theft.



    ------------------------------
    Debra Leckrone
    ------------------------------