Riley, first, what your team has pushed through is something else. Forced out by a crematorium narcotics evacuation, rebuilding from a warehouse, running a Capital Campaign, and you still ran free TNR on 136 cats with 82 more booked before August. That is prevention under fire. Respect.
Brandi is right about Candid, and here is how to make it pay off fast for TNR specifically. When you search the Foundation Directory, do not just search "animal welfare," search for the funders already giving to TNR and community cat work, then look at who else those same funders support. That reverse lookup surfaces the cat-specific money that a broad animal search buries.
A few TNR and community cat funding sources worth chasing:
Petco Love has funded spay/neuter and community cat work at real scale, and they favor organizations doing exactly what you are, high-volume access to care that keeps animals out of the shelter. PetSmart Charities funds spay/neuter and has specific community cat and access-to-care grants. Maddie's Fund itself, right here, has grant opportunities and this forum will tell you when cycles open. Two Mauds is small and cat-specific and worth a look. And do not overlook your state's animal-friendly license plate fund and any local community foundations, because a shelter that just survived what yours did is exactly the local story those funders want to back.
One angle for your applications, since you mentioned the Capital Campaign is eating the big grants and community donations. Frame TNR as the thing that protects the investment. Every cat you fix is intake you never have to house in the new building. Funders who care about the capital project should care about the program that keeps it from overflowing on day one. That reframing can unlock money that would otherwise all flow to the building. Always check their funding cycles and verify eligibility.
Happy to compare notes on the access-to-care side. We run a prevention-first nonprofit and spay/neuter access is the whole ballgame for us too.
------------------------------
Join The Shift To Prevention.
BJ Adkins
Founder/Director
Animal-Angels Foundation
Pinson, AL
calendy.com/animal-angels
bjadkins@animal-angels.organimal-angelsfoundation.org
------------------------------