Michelle,
I think I found some resources for you but please look into them more to make sure they work for your organization specifically.
MetLife Pet Insurance
-They offer insurance to shelters and individuals alike.
Insureon
-It looks like they'll work with you to find the best insurance for your organization.
Gateway Specialty Insurance
-Offers insurance to rescues, humane societies, shelters, etc.
XInsurance
-Animal shelter insurance opportunities.
I hope this helps!
Bailey
------------------------------
Bailey Evans
Grant Writer
Animal Allies Humane Society
MN
------------------------------